Opening the lab

Archimedes’ Principle  / CSEC Physics
upthrust = weight of fluid displaced
All labs
A metal block hanging from a spring balance and being lowered into a displacement can, with a beaker on a top-pan balance collecting the liquid that spills, a forces panel and a graph that builds from the recorded readings.
Weight, W
Upthrust, U
Pull of the string, T
Your readings
Line of best fit, or a reading with a problem
Theory

Set up the experiment

Human errors
Readings carry realistic slips, like a real student's
Block
Liquid in the can
Lower the blockin air
Graph
Show the theory
Draws what the principle predicts
Try this: weigh the block in air, then lower it a little at a time. Record several settings on the way down, some with the block only partly under the liquid, then one with it fully under. Wait for the pointer to stop each time. Then change the liquid and watch the upthrust change. Jumping the slider a long way in one go makes the liquid splash out.
How to answer: read the wording carefully. The upthrust equals the weight of liquid displaced, and the spring balance reads the weight in air minus the upthrust.
Spring balance
1.46N
Top-pan balance
0.0g
Depth of block
in air
Liquid density
1000kg/m³

Results table

Press Weigh in air, lower the block, then Record this setting.
Record at least 3 readings first

Working

What the experiment is about

When you lower an object into a liquid, the liquid pushes it upwards and the spring balance reading falls. At the same time the object pushes some liquid out of the way. The experiment verifies Archimedes’ principle: it shows that these two things are equal.

The aim in Paper 3 is: to verify Archimedes’ principle.

Archimedes’ principle

When an object is wholly or partly immersed in a fluid, the upthrust on it is equal to the weight of the fluid it displaces.

upthrust = weight of fluid displaced

In symbols, for a fluid of density ρ and an immersed volume V: U = ρ g V. In this lab g = 10 N/kg.

Example. 50 cm³ of a block is under water (1000 kg/m³). The upthrust is 1000 × 10 × 0.000050 = 0.5 N.

Forces and apparent weight

  • The weight, W of the block pulls it down. You measure it first, with the block hanging in air.
  • The upthrust, U from the liquid pushes it up.
  • The string pulls it up with a tension T. The spring balance reads T.

The block is at rest, so the forces balance: T + U = W. The reading in the liquid is the apparent weight, Wapp = W − U, so U = W − Wapp.

The forces panel on the stage draws these arrows to scale and updates as you lower the block.

What the upthrust depends on

  • The volume of the block under the liquid: more of it under, more liquid pushed aside, more upthrust.
  • The density of the liquid: salt water pushes harder than water, oil less.
  • Not the depth, once the block is fully under. Lower it further and the reading stays the same. That is the flat part of the “reading against depth” graph.
  • Not the density of the block. A heavier block of the same size gets the same upthrust.
Common CSEC error: saying the upthrust gets bigger the deeper the block goes. It grows only while the block is going under. Once it is fully immersed it stays constant.

The method, and the graph

  • Weigh the block in air with the spring balance: W.
  • Fill the displacement can to the spout and put an empty beaker under it. Put the beaker on the top-pan balance.
  • Lower the block gradually. Read the spring balance (Wapp) and the top-pan balance (the mass of liquid collected) when both are steady.
  • Work out U = W − Wapp. Work out the weight of liquid displaced: mass in kg × 10, which is mass in g ÷ 100.
  • Repeat with the block partly and fully under, and plot U against the weight of liquid displaced.

The graph is a straight line through the origin with gradient 1, and it has no unit, because both axes are in newtons. A gradient of 1 means U equals the weight displaced.

Common CSEC error: using the mass in grams as if it were the weight. 85 g of water weighs 0.85 N (85 ÷ 1000 × 10), not 85 N.

Must the line pass through the origin?

Archimedes’ principle says the upthrust U equals the weight of liquid displaced, so U is directly proportional to the weight displaced. A block that displaces no liquid feels no upthrust, so the graph must start at (0, 0).

Draw your line of best fit through (0, 0), with the points scattered either side of it. That scatter is human error in reading the balances. If your line misses the origin, the likely cause is a zero error on a balance, such as a top-pan balance that was not set to zero with the empty beaker on it, or a can that was not filled to the spout, so the first liquid displaced never reached the beaker.

Sinking and floating

This part goes a little beyond what Paper 3 asks, but it helps you understand the principle.

  • An object sinks if its weight is more than the upthrust it would get fully under. Its density is more than the liquid’s.
  • An object floats when the upthrust equals its weight. It sinks in until it displaces its own weight of liquid. A floating object does not displace its own volume.
  • All three blocks in this lab are denser than all three liquids, so they sink.

Precautions and sources of error

PrecautionWhy
Fill the can exactly to the spout firstAll the displaced liquid must spill into the beaker.
Lower the block graduallyNo splashing, so no liquid is lost.
Do not let the block touch the bottom or the sideThe can would hold up part of its weight and the reading would be too low.
Read the balances only when steadyA moving pointer cannot be read.
Use a string of negligible weightIt would add to the reading.
  • No instrument is perfectly accurate: the spring balance and the top-pan balance have limited scales.
  • The string is not exactly weightless.
  • The pointer keeps moving a little, so the reading is uncertain.
  • The hook and string push aside a little extra liquid.

This lab is a model. The block volumes are hidden and built in (aluminium 54 cm³, iron 40 cm³, brass 30 cm³), the spring balance is read to 0.02 N and the pointer bounce is modelled, not measured from a real balance.

Where Paper 3 asks it

His notes list Archimedes’ principle as set in May/June 2017 and May/June 2019, both Paper 3, Question 3. These questions usually ask you to complete a table (the upthrust from two spring balance readings, then the weight of liquid displaced from a mass), plot upthrust against weight displaced, find the gradient, and give precautions and sources of error. The Paper 3 practice tab walks through each of those.