What the experiment shows
A ball dropped onto a hard surface bounces back up, but never quite to the height it was let go from. HO is the release height and HR is the rebound height, both measured to the bottom edge of the ball.
Here a stack of paper towels sits under the ball. The more towels there are, the softer the landing, and the lower the ball bounces. The investigation asks: how does the rebound height change as the number of towels increases?
Honest note: the heights in this lab come from a model fitted to the worked example in the syllabus (a 60 cm drop gives about 43 cm with no towels and 30 cm with eight). It is not a measurement of a real ball. Real balls and towels give different numbers, but the same shape of graph.
Where the energy goes
- At the release height the ball has gravitational potential energy, mgh, and no kinetic energy.
- As it falls, GPE changes to kinetic energy.
- On landing, some energy is turned into heat and sound, and into squashing the towels and the ball. The rest sends the ball back up.
- At the top of the rebound the kinetic energy has changed back to GPE, but there is less of it.
The mass is the same at both heights, so it cancels. The fraction of energy kept is HR ÷ HO, and the fraction lost is 1 − HR ÷ HO. This lab uses g = 10 m/s².
The two graphs
- HR against N (number of towels) is a straight line sloping down. Its gradient is negative: the rebound height drops by the same amount for each extra towel. The unit is cm per towel.
- The y-intercept is the rebound height with no towels.
- HR against HO (the same ball, the same number of towels) is a straight line through the origin. Its gradient is the fraction of the height kept, with no unit.
With the rubber ball dropped from 60 cm the line is about HR = −1.6 N + 43.
Common CSEC error: writing the gradient as positive. The syllabus worked example writes the line as RH = 1.6N + 43, but the line slopes downwards, so the gradient is negative and the line is RH = −1.6N + 43.
Does this line pass through the origin?
It depends on the graph. For HR against N (towels) the line does not pass through the origin. At N = 0 the ball still bounces, so the intercept on the HR axis is the rebound height with no towels, for example about 43 cm from a 60 cm drop.
The line is not proportional: adding towels takes a fixed number of centimetres off the rebound, so there is no reason for it to start at (0, 0).
Must the line pass through the origin?
For HR against HO (same ball, same number of towels) it must. HR = fraction × HO, so a ball released from a height of zero rebounds to a height of zero: zero in gives zero out.
- Draw the line of best fit through (0, 0), with the points scattered either side of it. That scatter is human error.
- A line that misses the origin means a zero error on the rule, for example the 0 mark not level with the table or the towels, so every height is read too high or too low.
The method
- Fix a metre rule upright against a wall, with its zero level with the top of the towels.
- Hold the ball so that its bottom edge is level with the release mark, and let it go without pushing.
- Watch the first rebound at eye level and note the highest point of the bottom edge.
- Repeat three times and take the average HR.
- Add one towel at a time, keeping the same ball and the same release height, and repeat.
- Tabulate the towels, the readings and the average, then plot HR against N.
Common CSEC error: measuring the release height from the table. A thick stack makes the real drop shorter than it looks, so measure from the top of the towels.
Reading the peak
The hard part is that the ball is at the top of its rebound for a very short time, so the height is only a judgement. This is why every reading is repeated and averaged.
- With slow motion on, the peak lasts long enough to judge. At full speed it is a flash, so the scatter with Human errors on is larger.
- With Human errors on, each reading is out by a little under 1 cm (a little over 1 cm at full speed), because the peak is judged by eye, the eye is not exactly level with the mark and the ball is not released exactly from the mark. It is given to the nearest 0.5 cm. That is the size of scatter a careful student sees. Leave it off to see the exact line.
- Put your eye level with the peak. Looking from above or below makes the height look different (parallax).
Precautions and sources of error
| Precaution | Why |
| Bottom edge of the ball at the release mark | The same starting height every time. |
| Same release height and same ball | Only the towels may change. |
| Eye level with the rule when reading | Avoids parallax. |
| Drop without pushing, straight down | The ball rebounds along the rule. |
| Repeat three times and average | Reduces the effect of random errors. |
- The ball is at its peak for a very short time.
- Parallax when reading the rule.
- The ball may not fall vertically.
- The towels may compress or shift as the ball lands.
Using the line, and its limit
Because the points lie on a line, you can read a value between them. Put N = 5 into HR = −1.6 N + 43 and you get about 35 cm.
Be careful going outside your readings. The same line says HR = 0 at about 27 towels. A line is only trusted over the range you measured, so do not use it far beyond the biggest stack you tried.
Extension, not needed for CSEC: the coefficient of restitution is e = √(HR ÷ HO). It compares the speed after the bounce with the speed before.
Where it is asked
This is a standard School-Based Assessment investigation in the CSEC Physics syllabus. It trains the skills that Paper 3 marks: naming the variables, completing a table, plotting a graph, finding a gradient and intercept, giving precautions and sources of error, and writing a conclusion.
The Paper 3 practice tab walks through each of those parts using your own readings.