Opening the lab

Density of an Irregular Object  / CSEC Physics
ρ = m / V
All labs
A top-pan balance, a displacement can with a spout over a measuring cylinder, an irregular piece on a string, and a graph of mass against volume that builds from the readings.
Line of sight
Water
Your readings
Line of best fit

Set up the experiment

Human errors
Readings carry realistic slips, like a real student's
Material of the piece
Size of the piece
1. Weigh the piece
2. Fill the can to the spout
Try this: weigh the piece, fill the can, lower the piece gently and press Record reading. Do it for the four sizes of one material and watch the points line up. Then try dropping the piece in, reading from above, and choosing the wood.
How to answer: read the wording carefully. Density is mass per unit volume, and 1 g/cm³ is 1000 kg/m³.
Balance reads
0.0g
Volume read
–cm³
Density, m ÷ V
–g/cm³
Mean density
–g/cm³

Results table

Weigh a piece, find its volume, then press Record reading.
Record at least 3 readings first

Working

What density is

Density is the mass of a material in each unit of its volume. A dense material packs a lot of mass into a small space.

ρ = m ÷ V

Mass m is in kilograms or grams, volume V in cubic metres or cubic centimetres, and density ρ in kg/m³ or g/cm³.

To findUse
densityρ = m ÷ V
massm = ρ × V
volumeV = m ÷ ρ

The two units

One gram is 0.001 kg and one cubic centimetre is 0.000001 m³, so a number in g/cm³ is 1000 times bigger in kg/m³.

1 g/cm³ = 1000 kg/m³
  • Water is 1 g/cm³, which is 1000 kg/m³.
  • To change g/cm³ to kg/m³, multiply by 1000. To go the other way, divide by 1000.
Common CSEC error: multiplying by 100 or 10 000 instead of 1000, or leaving the answer in the wrong unit. Write the unit with every answer.

Regular and irregular objects

For a block, a ruler gives its length, width and height, and V = l × w × h. A stone or a lump of metal has no such formula, so its volume is found by displacement: put it in water and measure how much water it pushes aside. A solid that sinks pushes aside a volume of water equal to its own volume.

The method

  • Zero the top-pan balance, then find the mass m of the piece.
  • Fill the eureka (displacement) can until water runs out of the spout and stops dripping. Put an empty measuring cylinder under the spout.
  • Tie the piece to a string and lower it gently into the can. The water it pushes aside runs out of the spout into the cylinder.
  • Read the volume V of the water in the cylinder, with your eye level with the bottom of the meniscus.
  • Work out ρ = m ÷ V. Repeat with pieces of different size and find the mean, or plot a graph.

The graph and its gradient

  • Use several pieces of the same material and plot mass m on the vertical axis against volume V on the horizontal axis.
  • The points lie on a straight line through the origin: twice the volume has twice the mass.
  • The gradient = Δm ÷ ΔV = ρ, the density of the material, in g/cm³ when m is in grams and V in cm³.
  • Pick two points far apart on the line of best fit. Do not use the points of two of your readings.
Common CSEC error: using the final water level as the volume. The volume of the piece is the rise in the level, or the volume that runs out of the spout.

Must the line pass through the origin?

Yes. Mass and volume are proportional for one material: m = ρ × V. A piece with no volume has no mass, so zero in gives zero out, and the graph must go through (0, 0).

  • Draw the line of best fit through the origin, with the points scattered evenly either side of it. That scatter is human error.
  • If your line misses the origin, something is wrong. The most likely cause here is a zero error on the balance, which adds the same extra mass to every piece. Reading the volume as the final water level instead of the rise does the same kind of damage to the volume.

Things that float

A piece of wood sits on the water with part of it above the surface. It pushes aside only enough water to equal its weight, not its whole volume, so the water in the cylinder is less than the volume of the wood. This method cannot give the volume of something that floats, which is why the experiment needs a piece that sinks.

The reading would also be wrong for a piece that dissolves or soaks up water, because the water it takes in is not pushed aside.

Precautions and sources of error

PrecautionWhy
Choose a piece that sinks and does not dissolve or soak up waterOtherwise the water pushed aside is not equal to its volume.
Lower the piece gently and keep it off the sidesDropping it splashes water out of the can, and water clings where it touches the wall.
Read the bottom of the meniscus with your eye level with itFrom above you read too high, from below too low.
Zero the balance firstA zero error adds the same mass to every reading.
Fill the can until it stops drippingThe water level must start exactly at the spout.
  • The measuring cylinder only reads to about 0.5 cm³, so a small piece has a large percentage error in its volume.
  • The balance only reads to 0.1 g.
  • Water clinging to the piece, the spout or the can means not all of the displaced water reaches the cylinder.
  • Water splashed or spilt as the piece goes in.

Where Paper 3 asks it, and how this lab works

His notes list the density of an irregular object as set in May/June 2019 Paper 3 Question 2. Check the year against the past paper. The Paper 3 practice tab walks through the table, the mean, the conversion to kg/m³, the graph, the gradient, the precautions and the sources of error.

This lab is a model. Each material has a fixed density, set within the usual range for that material, and the sizes are chosen to read well on the cylinder. The loss from dropping the piece in, or touching the side of the can, is set to a typical size, not measured.